Once upon a few years ago, I read a book called The Magicians and Mrs Quent. It was a fun read, though the first third was pretty blatently taken from the pages of Pride and Prejudice and the second third was Jane Eyre all over.
Set in an alternate world version of Regency/Napoleonic Europe, there was magic and a gothic feel and some romance, all things that I just love.
So I bought the sequel (for a whole dollar!), and requested an advance copy of the third book. I started on The House on Durrow Street fairly recently, and read through a large chunk of it while I waited in the incredibly inhospitable waiting area for standby jurors.
It’s not a particularly light read- like the books to which the first in the series paid homage (homage isn’t quite strong enough- parody would indicate a humourous take- pastiche is the best term, though it’s far from satire), the language can be a bit formal, and sometimes even stiff. It’s a slow read, but one that builds and becomes more fascinating the further into the book one gets.
However-
And this is a huge stumbling block-
There are two things with which I take issue.
The first is oddly minor in comparison, though in almost any other book I would find it the strangest. There seem to be three types of magic- a rather cerebral, inherited magic held only by men in the nobility, a more earthy magic for women only, and illusions. The illusions are seen much as theater was in the associated English time: scandalous. The men (and it’s only men, again) are seen as almost a different species altogether. It took me a large portion of the first book before I realized that they were, indeed, human. I’d been under the impression that they were a sort of elf. Not elves, as it turns out- just gay men, every last one of them. For some reason.
There is one character with a minor talent for illusion magic, but he tries for respectable work in order to take care of his sister. Partway through the second book, he suddenly has a sexual encounter with his illusionist friend and finds that he can now work magic very well. I say suddenly, because I had to re-read the chapter because I thought I’d missed something. I had seen no indication that this character was either gay or attracted to his friend, but after that one drunken moment they were in love.
And that’s the minor issue. Some solid character development over a book and a half would have been handy there… Somehow a single chapter just doesn’t express the same thing.
The big one really hurts me in my science.
Yeah, it hurts me in my science. And I’m a person who is happy to let the brush of “fiction” cover over most physics issues, so long as there is an attempt at logic.
The earth that we live on turns around a slightly tilted axis, and orbits the sun elliptically. This creates days and nights that vary by season. Following me so far?
In the book, days and nights are called luminals and umbrals, and they vary in length. Not like they do in the real world, though. Think of a 24-hour time period. At equinox that’s 12 hours each of day and night. They will have a long day, a short night, a short day, a normal night, a normal day, a long night, a reeeeeeeally long day…predictable enough that almanacs come out each year so that people know how long of a day to expect, but random enough that science seems to have no part in it. If it were explained away as maaaaagic I’d have an easier time, but it seems intended to be just a physical, scientific fact of this single-sun world.
I searched for anything online explaining what kind of a rotation or orbit might cause something like this, but found only a link to a wikipedia entry on Nutation (think wobbling like a top), which wouldn’t explain the seeming randomness of these days and nights. Only a handful of people seem as bothered by this as I am.
Given the particulars of this world’s natural light, one might think that they would have developed a lot of alternative light sources and blackout curtains, but no. Instead they seem to attempt to live according to the days and nights as set by the sun. On long days they stay up as late as they can, on short nights they get up earlier.
I can’t think how a world could survive like this- no seasons, erratic days and nights. How would plants and crops properly grow? How are people not irritable from the lack of stable sleep patterns?
Why is this such a big deal in my mind that I don’t even know if I can continue reading?